Here is what Krugman wrote April 24 in the NYTs in a piece slamming Republican “zombies.” This is typical of the arrogant left picking their facts and ignoring the substance … and your common sense.
Start with Mr. Christie, who thought he was being smart and brave by proposing that we raise the age of eligibility for both Social Security and Medicare to 69. Doesn’t this make sense now that Americans are living longer?
No, it doesn’t. This whole line of argument should have died in 2007, when the Social Security Administration issued a report showing that almost all the rise in life expectancy has taken place among the affluent. The bottom half of workers, who are precisely the Americans who rely on Social Security most, have seen their life expectancy at age 65 rise only a bit more than a year since the 1970s. Furthermore, while lawyers and politicians may consider working into their late 60s no hardship, things look somewhat different to ordinary workers, many of whom still have to perform manual labor.
And while raising the retirement age would impose a great deal of hardship, it would save remarkably little money. In fact, a 2013 report from the Congressional Budget Office found that raising the Medicare age would save almost no money at all.
But Mr. Christie — like Jeb Bush, who quickly echoed his proposal — evidently knows none of this. The zombie ideas have eaten his brain.
Let’s start by conceding this point, raising the retirement age is not new and is not that great of an idea in the first place even though there is a long phase in period. But wait a minute, that was only one element of the Christie proposal to start a debate on fixing Social Security.
What about his other ideas that are right up the liberal progressives alley? You know, like eliminating the benefit entirely for those with higher incomes in retirement? What about the idea of no payroll tax for workers age 62 and older or more means testing for Medicare? What could be more “progressive” than that!
And indeed, give Christie some credit for sticking his neck out with specifics, good or bad, viable or not this early in the game.
Take a look here are what Christie said in full. Did Paul Krugman miss this story😉
QUINNSCOMMENTARY 