A health insurance deductible versus premiums

What your health insurance deductible actually means.

Let’s say your insurance premium is $1,000 a month. That’s a fixed cost. No matter what health care you use or don’t use you still pay $1,000.

You can lower that $1,000 premium with a deductible. You lower a fixed cost (monthly premium) in favor of a possible cost (the deductible) and assume a known risk you can plan for.

Keep this in mind. Roughly 50-60% (or more) of the U.S. population under age 65 have less than $1,000 in annual healthcare spending in a given year. This includes people with $0 spending (typically 15-20% or higher among younger groups) and those with low spending (e.g., preventive care, minor visits, or prescriptions).

A deductible saves you money.

Rough Estimates

From available data and examples:

Switching to a $500 deductible: Premiums often drop 10-25% (sometimes more). For your $1,000/month plan, this might mean a reduction of $100–$250/month, bringing it to roughly $750–$900/month. Savings are meaningful but not dramatic.

Switching to a $1,000 deductible: Reductions are typically larger, often 20-40% in some contexts. This could lower your premium by $200–$400/month, to roughly $600–$800/month.

You can get a rough idea of potential savings by comparing actual plans.

During the first year of coverage you put the premium savings aside so you have the cash in the even you actually incurred an expense subject to the deductible.

You should also use a Health Savings Account (HSA) for a better deal.

Deductibles are not a “rip off” as some people think. A deductible very likely saves you money year after year … especially if you plan properly.

Leave a Reply