Just fix Social Security, stop the wrangling, stop the rhetoric laced with misinform and stop trying to shift the financial burden to the 6% of workers who earn above the taxable wage cap.
Workers need to pay more and retirees need to take less future COLA increases.
All that needs be done is to increase the payroll tax rate and tweak the future COLA calculation, thus current workers and current retirees share the cost of making and keeping Social Security solvent.
According to the SS Trustees, if the following change was made in 2026, then the combined OASDI program would be solvent for the full 75-year projection period ending in 2100:
Increase the payroll tax rate from 12.40 percent to 16.65 percent starting in January 2026. (Too late)
According to the BLS the average weekly wage is $1,307.20 in October 2026 for all employees on private non-farm payrolls. In this example that results in tax increase for the average worker of $27.78 (4.25% of wage = $55.56 per week 1/2 paid by the employer).
If substantial actions are deferred until the OASDI program reaches reserve depletion, (2032/2033) significantly larger changes would be concentrated on fewer years and fewer generations.
For example, if the following change was made in 2034, then 75-year solvency through 2100 would be achieved:
Increase the payroll tax rate from 12.40 percent to 17.30 percent starting in 2034.
Based on the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB) SS calculator, a 4.3% increase in payroll tax will close 100% percent of 75-year shortfall (66% of shortfall closed in 75th year). However, Social Security would need a 12% across-the-board benefit reduction in 2099.
An accelerated increase in the taxable wage cap would also be acceptable thus lowering the tax rate provided those taxed wages were credited for the benefit calculation at 5% to 10% (less than the current lowest percentage used in the benefit formula (see tiers below)
These payroll taxes dedicated to Social Security funding and future benefits are, in effect, forced savings. And, the reduction in net pay will quickly be absorbed and unnoticed. The direct impact on workers can be reduced if employers were required to pay something more than half the total tax.
Also, the tax increases mentioned above could be lower when coupled with changes in the COLA calculation.
COLA modification options:
According to the Social Security Administration’s actuarial estimates:
Switching from the current CPI-W index to a chained CPI (which would reduce annual COLAs by about 0.3 percentage points on average) would eliminate about 16% of Social Security’s 75-year actuarial shortfall.
Reducing all COLAs by 0.5 percentage points annually would eliminate about 27% of the shortfall.
Reducing all COLAs by 1 percentage point annually would eliminate about 51% of the shortfall.
The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB) has also analyzed targeted COLA approaches:
A COLA cap that limits increases for beneficiaries with larger benefits would close roughly 10% of the solvency gap if applied to the top quarter of retirees.
CRFB estimates that using chained CPI would close roughly 15% of the long-term funding gap.
A more aggressive flat-dollar COLA (everyone gets the same dollar increase rather than the same percentage increase) could close about 40% to 50% of the 75-year shortfall, depending on how it is structured.
Social Security benefit calculation
2027 PIA Formula Brackets (the average indexed earnings are changed annually)
To calculate the Primary Insurance Amount for 2027, Average Indexed Monthly Earnings (AIME) are split into three tiers using these bend points: [1, 2]

