We can’t control what others do and we can’t stop misfortune from striking. But we can control our own actions. Those who are financially prudent will most likely enjoy success, even if events don’t always go their way.
Sen. Ron Johnson “Social Security is a “scam” and should be “shut down”
Irresponsible at best, more like ignorant, this is one of the people undermining confidence in your government and dividing our country.
Republican Sen. Ron Johnson said on Wednesday that Social Security is a “scam” and should be “shut down” ahead of a Senate hearing about the earned-benefit retirement program.
It’s grotesque, and at this point there really is no way to fix Social Security,” he said. “It is a Ponzi scheme. You can’t fix it. You just shut it down and hope you can recover some of your money.” The committee’s hearing, called “Social Security: The Reality,” was scheduled for a few hours after his comments. MarketWatch 11-18-26
Oh wait, I didn’t really mean that.
Social Security is not a Ponzi scheme. It was never intended to be a get-rich-quick scheme or a reward for outliving everyone else. It was designed to provide a meaningful measure of financial security when working is no longer an option.
Social Security is a social-insurance program funded by workers and employers to provide support in retirement, prevent vulnerable people from falling into poverty and provide economic stability during downturns. It is at risk of a shortfall in funding, not annihilation. The Moneyist MarketWatch 11/10/26
Johnson is full of brilliant ideas.
August 2022: Wanted annual congressional votes
Johnson proposed changing Social Security from mandatory spending to discretionary spending.
That would mean Congress would have to vote on its funding every year rather than benefits being automatically paid to eligible recipients under existing law.
He argued this would give Congress more oversight. Critics warned that it could make benefits vulnerable to political battles. Source: The Washington Post
“You just shut it down and hope you can recover some of your money.”
This comment alone demonstrates Johnson doesn’t understand what Social Security is and was intended to be. This comment implies it’s some kind of retirement investment fund built on the taxes you paid, that you have money allocated to your account. It’s not, it’s a broad social insurance program helping Americans of all ages.
Johnson’s statements are as ignorant as saying your Medicare payroll taxes for Part A should be returned if you are never hospitalized after age 65 because you didn’t use the coverage you invested in.
I guess Johnson realized that because as a true politician …
At the hearing later that day, he said, “I’m not saying shut down Social Security… my proposal is, let’s change the law so we don’t reduce benefits.”
He has also suggested using general revenue to fund Social Security that is a very bad idea.
Exactly what is his proposal? He sounds as coherent as Trump.
By the way, this man is so in tune with the needs of the American people has no need for Social Security himself.
From his latest disclosure — the 2025 report filed May 14, 2026 — the midpoint estimate of his net worth is about $79.0 million, with a range of $26.7 million to $131.4 million and $0 in disclosed liabilities. About the 21st highest in Congress.
We have not paid for all the benefits and in addition we have not adjusted the (tax) revenue to accommodate the changing demographics for ratio of workers to retirees. That is no secret. Go into trustee reports going back over a decade and they have been warning Congress to take action sooner rather than later. I have posted their words several times on the blog.
There is nothing wrong with the basic design. The problem is leaving revenue changes to Congress. As I have said before, the tax revenue should be adjusted automatically each year based on the latest actuarial 75 year projections, including consideration of any law changes. The program would always be funded and we would not be in this mess now.
Sad, but true Americans need a forced savings plan for their future retirement, the individual saving and planning data always support this. Americans are not great at planning for the future … and NOT because they can’t afford to. It’s nice to talk about what should be, what responsible people SHOULD do, but it’s reality that matters like it or not.
And by the way, the same holds true for health care as well.
This man is worth millions.. how can he understand what its like to try to survive on Social Security.. if anything it needs to be increased in payments. Senior Citizens need this for everyday living needs.. this man has no idea what ist like to be without any necessities.. he needs to stay out of this Social Security plans..
Social Security is certainly a social, legal Ponzi scheme (paying returns to earlier taxpayers using money from newer taxpayers) – where Congress acts as Ponzi deciding who pays, how much, and who benefits. The benefit isn’t earned. It is not based on a valid contract. Today, it varies based on your marital status upon commencement. It is an entitlement – Congress could terminate it tomorrow and forgive the debt instruments held by the trust.
Obviously, I don’t agree with Senator Johnson’s “solutions” – as I have repeatedly confirmed here. However, he speaks the truth in terms of how we got here.
From yesterday’s Wall Street Journal:
Ron Johnson Tells the Social Security Truth – The Wisconsin Senator dares to show how the current system is unsustainable.
The Greek philosopher Diogenes searched the streets for an honest man, and in Washington he’d still be looking. But an exception is Republican Sen. Ron Johnson, who insists on telling hard fiscal truths to a political class that doesn’t want to hear it.
Average life expectancy has increased to 79.1 from 63.6 in 1940, the Social Security retirement age has risen only to 67 from 65 during this time.
Jack Note: More importantly, today’s 65 year old man has a life expectancy of 17.9 years, vs. 11.9 in 1940, 50% longer; and today’s 65 year old woman has a life expectancy of 20.7 years, vs. 13.4 in 1940, 54% longer.
In 1940 there were 159.4 workers for every Social Security beneficiary. Last year the ratio was 2.6 to one.
Inflation-adjusted Social Security outlays have nearly tripled between 1990 and 2025 – the major culprit is a formula that Congress adopted in 1977 that adjusts benefits based on growth in wages, which have generally increased faster than prices. If not for that change, “Social Security would likely be sustainable today,” the Johnson report notes
The Social Security “trust fund” has always been an accounting fiction since Congress has spent the money collected from payroll taxes.
Uncapping the Social Security (wage base ignors the fact that) Social Security taxes are already progressive. “The top 10% of income earners pay approximately 24% of the payroll taxes and receive approximately 11% of Social Security benefits. while, the bottom 60% of earners pay 32% of payroll taxes and get 53% of benefits.
Nothing in his report is inaccurate or misleading. The fact that you don’t like his accurate characterization of Social Security as a legal Ponzi scheme, or that you and I don’t like his solutions, doesn’t change the fact that Congress has promised more than it was willing to tax.
In past posts, I’ve highlighted those who identified the issue (commissions, etc.) but failed to take action – Clinton, Bush II, Obama. Even the changes approved by Reagan in 1983 were insufficient to overcome past vote-buying schemes to improve benefits far beyond the taxes levied – as approved by Roosevelt (1939) and Carter (1977).
Indefensible was the most recent vote buying scheme approved by President Biden (2024) – to increase benefits to public sector employees who did not pay FICA taxes on the majority of their wages.
By that definition the entire federal government is a Ponzi scheme, younger generations are always paying to fulfill past commitments.
“The Social Security “trust fund” has always been an accounting fiction since Congress has spent the money collected from payroll taxes.”
Accounting, yes, fiction no. The law replaces cash with bonds, a legal obligation, just like savings bonds, or corporate bonds. Just like those investments, the borrower decides how to spend the proceeds from the investment it sells. SS has worked fine that way since 1939 and to imply that has anything to do with the fiscal state of the trust is irresponsible. The trust has been redeeming the bonds since 2021.
And as you know, the trust will not be depleted until AFTER all the treasury bonds are redeemed. No doubt coming up with the cash to do so from the Treasury probably will add to the deficit, but the borrowing to run the government would have come from other selling of bonds any case as long as we spend more than our revenue. Social Security is not the only intragovernmental trust fund.
AL LINDQUIST
Excellent, as usual Jack–no insurance company could run a scheme like this–I wonder if we paid for all the added benefits since 1939?
LikeLiked by 1 person
We have not paid for all the benefits and in addition we have not adjusted the (tax) revenue to accommodate the changing demographics for ratio of workers to retirees. That is no secret. Go into trustee reports going back over a decade and they have been warning Congress to take action sooner rather than later. I have posted their words several times on the blog.
There is nothing wrong with the basic design. The problem is leaving revenue changes to Congress. As I have said before, the tax revenue should be adjusted automatically each year based on the latest actuarial 75 year projections, including consideration of any law changes. The program would always be funded and we would not be in this mess now.
Sad, but true Americans need a forced savings plan for their future retirement, the individual saving and planning data always support this. Americans are not great at planning for the future … and NOT because they can’t afford to. It’s nice to talk about what should be, what responsible people SHOULD do, but it’s reality that matters like it or not.
And by the way, the same holds true for health care as well.
LikeLike
This man is worth millions.. how can he understand what its like to try to survive on Social Security.. if anything it needs to be increased in payments. Senior Citizens need this for everyday living needs.. this man has no idea what ist like to be without any necessities.. he needs to stay out of this Social Security plans..
LikeLike
Social Security is certainly a social, legal Ponzi scheme (paying returns to earlier taxpayers using money from newer taxpayers) – where Congress acts as Ponzi deciding who pays, how much, and who benefits. The benefit isn’t earned. It is not based on a valid contract. Today, it varies based on your marital status upon commencement. It is an entitlement – Congress could terminate it tomorrow and forgive the debt instruments held by the trust.
Obviously, I don’t agree with Senator Johnson’s “solutions” – as I have repeatedly confirmed here. However, he speaks the truth in terms of how we got here.
From yesterday’s Wall Street Journal:
Ron Johnson Tells the Social Security Truth – The Wisconsin Senator dares to show how the current system is unsustainable.
The Greek philosopher Diogenes searched the streets for an honest man, and in Washington he’d still be looking. But an exception is Republican Sen. Ron Johnson, who insists on telling hard fiscal truths to a political class that doesn’t want to hear it.
Nothing in his report is inaccurate or misleading. The fact that you don’t like his accurate characterization of Social Security as a legal Ponzi scheme, or that you and I don’t like his solutions, doesn’t change the fact that Congress has promised more than it was willing to tax.
In past posts, I’ve highlighted those who identified the issue (commissions, etc.) but failed to take action – Clinton, Bush II, Obama. Even the changes approved by Reagan in 1983 were insufficient to overcome past vote-buying schemes to improve benefits far beyond the taxes levied – as approved by Roosevelt (1939) and Carter (1977).
Indefensible was the most recent vote buying scheme approved by President Biden (2024) – to increase benefits to public sector employees who did not pay FICA taxes on the majority of their wages.
LikeLike
By that definition the entire federal government is a Ponzi scheme, younger generations are always paying to fulfill past commitments.
“The Social Security “trust fund” has always been an accounting fiction since Congress has spent the money collected from payroll taxes.”
Accounting, yes, fiction no. The law replaces cash with bonds, a legal obligation, just like savings bonds, or corporate bonds. Just like those investments, the borrower decides how to spend the proceeds from the investment it sells. SS has worked fine that way since 1939 and to imply that has anything to do with the fiscal state of the trust is irresponsible. The trust has been redeeming the bonds since 2021.
And as you know, the trust will not be depleted until AFTER all the treasury bonds are redeemed. No doubt coming up with the cash to do so from the Treasury probably will add to the deficit, but the borrowing to run the government would have come from other selling of bonds any case as long as we spend more than our revenue. Social Security is not the only intragovernmental trust fund.
LikeLike